How much the time can bear
Many birth records say only ‘around sunrise’ or carry a time rounded to the half hour. Over thirty minutes the lagna advances on average about seven and a half degrees: the navāṃśa lagna can change twice or more, the daśāṃśa lagna two or three times, and the Placidus cusp sub-lords several times.
These are averages: the lagna rises faster or slower depending on the sign and the latitude, so at Delhi’s latitude the navāṃśa lagna changes anywhere from about every ten to about every sixteen minutes, and at London’s from about every six to about every nineteen. Pretending that such a time supports the finest techniques is a methodological error. The honest question is which conclusions survive across the whole plausible range, and what to do about the questions that do not.
- Rāśi chart: usually stable
- Navāṃśa: about every 13 minutes on average
- Daśāṃśa: about every 12 minutes on average
- Ṣaṣṭyaṃśa: about every 2 minutes on average
The chart of the question
Praśna, horary astrology, casts a chart for the moment a sincere question is put to the astrologer and judges the question from that chart. In the Kerala tradition, systematised in the seventeenth-century Praśna Mārga, the moment is read together with the querist’s ārūḍha, omens (nimitta) and calculated points such as the trisphuṭa.
Praśna is not a natal chart with missing data. It is a different instrument with its own rules, and it answers the question asked rather than describing a whole life.
KP horary
Krishnamurti Paddhati offers a horary method in which the querist chooses a number from 1 to 249. Each number corresponds to one of KP’s 249 sub-divisions, which fixes the ascendant of the horary chart, and the question is judged through cusp sub-lords and ruling planets at the time of judgment.
Praśna Mārga and KP horary should each be judged within its own rules. Where both are used, their conclusions are compared, not blended.
Intake discipline
A horary chart is valid only once. The number is taken, or the moment recorded, when the question is genuinely formulated, and it is not regenerated until a more comforting chart appears. The question itself is recorded in the querist’s words.
A horary chart must also stay labelled as a horary chart in any client record, so that a later consultation never mistakes it for a birth chart.
Praśna and rectification
Praśna answers an urgent question when the natal time is too uncertain. It can also help decide whether rectification is worthwhile, because classical Praśna techniques compare the chart of the question with candidate natal charts.
Rectification itself is a separate task with its own standard of evidence, set out in Grahvani’s study of rectification by held-out events.
THE GRAHVANI PRINCIPLEFine natal techniques cannot be applied honestly to a birth time that cannot bear them. Praśna shifts the authority to the chart of the question, with its own rules and its own discipline.
